Showing posts with label Arizona Shooting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arizona Shooting. Show all posts

1.15.2011

Violent Rhetoric

Since the Arizona shootings, our media elite have been arguing about whether violent rhetoric, mostly from the right at this time, can inspire violence in people. Though it may inspire some random acts of violence, I see more danger in its ability to undermine the people's faith in the poilitcal system.

When bombarded 24/7 with claims like "Bush stole the election", "there was massive voter fraud", "where's the birth certificate", or "Obama's a Socialist/Marxist, Kenyan/Muslim" people begin to question the legitimacy of system. When they see the system as illegitmate or corrupt beyond repair, they often see no reason to play by the established rules and may instead, see taking matters into their own hands as a viable alternative. They vote with bullets and violence instead of at the ballot box. We see this in the developing world a lot and I believe the rhetoric we hear today is pushing us in that direction.

This is what happens when we reach that point.

Tunisia between Democracy and Anarchy Informed Comment

Tunisians woke Saturday morning to delirious joy at the advent of political liberty, but many worried about the simultaneous advent of social anarchy.

The fall of the government of dictator Zine al-Abedin Ben Ali after 23 years left behind a number of political and social vacuums. As for the security breach, it was gangs and Mafia that attempted to step into it. Friday afternoon and into the evening witnessed systematic looting in Tunis and in some other cities. Men in masks attacked civilians. Some Tunisians on the internet accused the police of going rogue. One tweeted, “many policemen have been arrested by the army, many gunshots around presidential palace.” Some tweets are calling the rogue police “counter-revolutionaries.”

Aljazeera says that cars with no license plates cruised the streets looking for opportunities for larceny. Helicopters dropped paratroopers in some towns to combat the looters. One Tunisian interviewed from a quarter of Tunis said, “There is complete disorder here. Families are afraid.” One eyewitness tweeted, “… what a night in Bourj Louzir, robbers still doing their things, and locals keep fighting them, at 3:45 am.” Some tweets report the formation of neighborhood ad hoc militias to patrol for safety. One warned that forming factious militias had been the downfall of Iraqis under US rule. (Iraq is thus a negative, not a positive, example for Tunisian oppositionists). The central train station and some supermarkets were set ablaze late Friday afternoon.

Be careful about what you wish for.

tnb

1.13.2011

Arizona Shootings - Wikileaks

The right thinks,...

that Bill O'Reilly screaming "Tiller, The baby Killer" multiple times on prime time TV couldn't possibly have influenced the shooter of Dr. Tiller

and

That presenting Obama as a, ... socialist, communist, marxist, kenyan, no-birth-certificate holding, pal'd-around-with-terrorists hoodlum who's trying to take your gun, your bible, AND put your parents in front of death panels, while taking over the auto industry and the banks in a socialist takeover complete with a bunch of those evil Czar guys,...... couldn't possibly cause some nutcase to try to assassinate him.

but

They want to execute Julian Assange of Wikileaks because they think some of the documents that he was given, and could release, could get someone killed.

WTF?

tnb

Arizona Shootings - Palin

The Palin camp must have been scared initially. They took down the gunsite map, at least for a while. If they didn't think it was wrong, why did they take it down? Anyway, now that she's pretty sure he's not a teabagger, she's all fangs.

The surveyor symbol comment has to be one of the worst cover-your-ass-i-know-its-stupid-but-its-the-best-we've-got-right-now comments ever made by an american politician. I'd put it slightly worse than "I didn't inhale". Though in Palin's defense, I don't think she ever said it herself. It was from one of her minions.

tnb

1.12.2011

Arizona Shooting - Rhetoric

A good article here: TAPPED Archive | The American Prospect including this cut.

The rhetoric of violence is not the only kind of rhetoric that encourages violence. The apocalyptic rhetoric we've seen from some on the right, most notably Glenn Beck, should be part of this discussion too. When Beck portrays Barack Obama as the head of a socialist/communist/Nazi conspiracy whose goal is the literal destruction of America, he is implicitly encouraging violence. If that really were the nature of the administration, and our liberty really were on the verge of being snuffed out, violence would be justified.

The apocalyptic rhetoric is what we really should be talking about. The flat-out making stuff up and feeding it to the masses 24/7 just to fuel and build the hate. I think it dwarfs the "violent rhetoric".

This type of rhetoric has always been around but I think its reached a dangerous level in the last few years. I thought the left took it too far with the "Bush stole the election" talk but the right has gone off-the-charts since the the Obama win. Limbaugh, the Fox crew, talk radio, Palin, Bachmann are all guilty of this rabble-rousing. They're all trying to out-crazy the each other.

I thought there might be a lull after the Arizona shooting, and there might have been if the shooter had ties to one side or the other, but it looks like he was just an independent nutcase so both sides are ramping it up trying to put him in the other guy's camp.

tnb